Tuesday, 10 December 2019

But What About Tory Islamophobia?



Someone who might usually support the Labour party, and traditionally considers themselves 'left wing' (as I have done), are often of the conviction, for ideological reasons I'll not expand upon here, that 'their side' is the side of moral worth and all opposition is therefore morally less worthy. Thus when confronted with the evidence of anti-Semitism in the Labour party, the very common instinctive reaction is to point to 'Islamophobia' in the Tory party. Afterall, (the reasoning goes) this sounds like an equivalent kind of prejudice that must be as rampant as anti-Semitism in the Labour party, if it is not even worse. Although there may be apparent issues with prejudices in all the large political organizations, including the Conservative party, this 'whataboutary' comparison of Labour anti-Semitism and Tory 'Islamophobia' is a false equivalence fallacy. I've looked into some of the details and tried to briefly outline them here.

Sunday, 17 November 2019

Top 10 Reasons Why State Broadband is a Bad Idea





Labour policy: 'British Broadband'... state controlled UK internet service provision. 
Brilliant.

Here's a top 10  countdown of arguments why this is a very very bad idea (1 & 2 are the clinchers for me).

Thursday, 26 September 2019

Parliament's Broken Moral Compass: The Power Play Over 'Inflammatory' Language



The unprincipled hypocrisy of the calls from the Liberal Democrats for the Prime Minister to 'moderate your language' is astounding. The words singled out for condemnation are 'surrender' and 'humbug', yet the Liberal Democrats are blocking a democratic General Election and seek to overturn the democratic referendum that they voted to enact via Article 50, and this is all done under their carefully chosen slogan 'B*llocks to Brexit'; an equivalent message to - and barely less intemperate language than - 'B*llocks to the individual sovereignty of the leave voter, b*llocks to your vote, B*llocks to you'.
Kettle. Pot. Black.

Thursday, 15 August 2019

The Caroline Lucas Affair: Intersectionalist Malevolence Demonstrated in the Mainstream




This is the data from which I derive the view that we are now at what I call the 'peak narrative' of intersectionalism:

"Charting The New York Times' Narrative"
source: Chris Menahan, InformationLiberation
As much as its adherents would want and perhaps imagine it to be so, a utopian ideal of an end to all of life's sufferings, stresses and strains can never be the outcome of applied intersectionality. The goal of its radical followers seems to be to dismantle the functioning institutions, but the ideology is completely absent on ideas with what to replace them (an opportunity, should such a catastrophe occur,  a would-be tyrant of any ideology would relish). Whatever social and political direction liberal democratic civilisations take in consequence of this intersectionalist barminess, it is starting to look very much as though it will be played out in the coming months or years. It is my opinion that we are at a zenith of intersectionailist influence from the BS narrative in the mainstream and, if the ideology is to be rejected and liberal meritocracy and blind justice are to regain traction in the mainstream, then perhaps for many, this story will be one of a few pivotal stories in the coming months that are 'penny drop', counter narrative moments:

"Caroline Lucas apologises for proposing all-white female emergency cabinet"
source: The Independent

Thursday, 16 May 2019

Cheerleading 'Online Harms'


This is an article on the issues that surround this article published in The Metro, the link for which appears as follows in some social media, including the headline:


https://metro.co.uk/2019/05/08/end-free-speech-natural-solution-hatred-shared-online-9437991/


Friday, 8 March 2019

The False Equivalencies of James O'Brien



A video was shared on social media featuring James O'Brien.
On Facebook, the video is accompanied throughout with the caption:
"James O'Brien absolutely nails how the media protects the Tories over their rampant racism"
source: https://www.facebook.com/EvolvePolitics/posts/2196065960645339?__tn__=C-R

The video predominantly makes several false equivalence fallacies: Religious ideologies are equivilent,  Criticism is equivilent to prejudice, lsIamophobia is equivalent to Antisemitism, lsIamophobia is equivilent to racism, therefore criticism is racism and equivalent to Antisemitism.






Several errors there...

Saturday, 23 February 2019

Analysis: Sajid Javid, Shamima Begum and UK Citizenry



I made a couple of lengthy posts on social media regarding UK Home Secretary Sajid Javid's attempt to strip former ISIS collaborator Shamima Begum of her UK citizenship, while she is in a refugee camp in Syria (src: https://is.gd/Jy1CBE). I've decided to reproduce them here.

Wednesday, 30 January 2019

My complaint to the BBC about their 'Covington boys' article




This is the current version of the article in question, (marked as published 20 Jan):
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-46935701

This is the earliest version on Internet Archive captured at 07:53 Jan 20
https://web.archive.org/web/20190120075324/https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-46935701

A second article was published the following day (21 Jan), the current version is here:
 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-46943364
This is the earliest version on Internet Archive:
https://web.archive.org/web/20190121121301/https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-46943364

A 1hr46m YouTube video of the entire incident marked as published on 20 Jan:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t3EC1_gcr34


Another short video pub 20 Jan:
https://twitter.com/Uncle_Jimbo/status/1086796139817504768 

Another short video pub 19 Jan:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=npX801xLSFY

 MY COMPLAINT TO THE BBC (sent 20 Jan, aprox midnight)


 
Your article on the BBC homepage: "Teens taunting Native American sparks outcry" is objectively incorrect, especially that headline. It is clear that BBC journalists did not properly research the available material. Instead a subjective and uninformed opinion dictated an assumption of what occured. The video you have linked to in your article is edited in a manner as to be deceptive, but regardless shows no evidence of any harrasment or taunting towards the man.

WOKESPEAK

A Single Sentence Dictionary of Social Justice Terminology This page: Introduction Dictionary Exposing The Motte and Bailey Usage Examples ...