Someone who might usually support the Labour party, and traditionally considers themselves 'left wing' (as I have done), are often of the conviction, for ideological reasons I'll not expand upon here, that 'their side' is the side of moral worth and all opposition is therefore morally less worthy. Thus when confronted with the evidence of anti-Semitism in the Labour party, the very common instinctive reaction is to point to 'Islamophobia' in the Tory party. Afterall, (the reasoning goes) this sounds like an equivalent kind of prejudice that must be as rampant as anti-Semitism in the Labour party, if it is not even worse. Although there may be apparent issues with prejudices in all the large political organizations, including the Conservative party, this 'whataboutary' comparison of Labour anti-Semitism and Tory 'Islamophobia' is a false equivalence fallacy. I've looked into some of the details and tried to briefly outline them here.
Tuesday, 10 December 2019
But What About Tory Islamophobia?
Someone who might usually support the Labour party, and traditionally considers themselves 'left wing' (as I have done), are often of the conviction, for ideological reasons I'll not expand upon here, that 'their side' is the side of moral worth and all opposition is therefore morally less worthy. Thus when confronted with the evidence of anti-Semitism in the Labour party, the very common instinctive reaction is to point to 'Islamophobia' in the Tory party. Afterall, (the reasoning goes) this sounds like an equivalent kind of prejudice that must be as rampant as anti-Semitism in the Labour party, if it is not even worse. Although there may be apparent issues with prejudices in all the large political organizations, including the Conservative party, this 'whataboutary' comparison of Labour anti-Semitism and Tory 'Islamophobia' is a false equivalence fallacy. I've looked into some of the details and tried to briefly outline them here.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
WOKESPEAK
A Single Sentence Dictionary of Social Justice Terminology This page: Introduction Dictionary Exposing The Motte and Bailey Usage Examples ...
-
A Single Sentence Dictionary of Social Justice Terminology This page: Introduction Dictionary Exposing The Motte and Bailey Usage Examples ...
-
What can be reasonably determined about Britain First's Jayda Francen from just the three re-tweeted tweets is that she is not a rel...
-
I am no fan of Johnson. I have my doubts about his merits as a politician. I have no loyalty to him and I have no doubt that many of his...
-
Subject: Please oppose acclimatization to coerced consent for medical experiments and procedures Dear NNN NNN, Thank you again for your p...
-
The moral standard with which historical figures like Edward Colston (and Jefferson, Washington, Columbus and others in the...
-
This was a sarcastic meme by mathematician James Lindsay that exposed the idiocy and authoritarianism of the Critical Social Justice ideo...
-
The media, politicians and government bodies are rarely providing CONTEXT on the current epidemic. Below are 3 decontextualised factoids...
-
When, twenty five years ago , Kate Mulgrew was cast as captain Kathryn Janeway, the lead role in Star Trek Voyager, I was indifferent to t...
-
Trevor Noah's response to French ambassador's complaint about his racist joke does not stand up to scrutiny Original joke (1st ...